Ice Fishing FAQ

Here are some basic questions and answers to get you planned your next ice fishing adventure.

Where should I ice fish on a lake?

First, I recommend calling the local bait shop and asking about the ice thickness and safety. Ask to see a map of the lake or check the state agency website for a lake map. The best first place to start fishing on a new lake during early ice season is the largest weed bed on the lake. Ice anglers are usually friendly and helpful so ask for advice.

When ice fishing for the first time, what is the best lure/bait to try first?

It's always best to stop in the local bait shop and ask what the fish have been biting. Start with a small jig, preferably tungsten and a few maggots. If another angler is catching fish and you are struggling, take the time to watch and learn.

Live bait or artificial lures?

Generally speaking live bait will almost always outperform artificial bait. Always start with a few maggots. Fine tune the number of maggots from one to a full hook depending on what the fish prefer. I actually prefer plastics though because they never die and have multiple colors and sizes. Remember that you do not want your maggots to freeze, so consider keeping them in a tightly closed container in a pock or close to your body so they do not freeze.

What are some signs above the ice that you notice that might help to know there are fish below?

If the ice is covered in snow, look for holes that have already been created. These probably had some good activity already. In a shanty town of fished holes (group of shanties close together) check the ones that look like they have been fished the most.

Which is best, a power auger or a hand auger?

Both devices work well. I typically use a hand auger early in the season, then a power auger when the ice is thicker mid-season. A hand auger is nice because it's a little quieter, so you are less likely to spook the fish.

What ice fishing technique do you recommend a novice try first?

The best thing about ice fishing is the fish will always tell you what they want. You just need to pay attention. Always check fishing reports or forums for current information. There is nothing more simple or successful than jigging from the bottom up until you find where the fish are biting. Jig for a while on the bottom. If you don't get a bit, pull your bait/lure up a foot and jig there. Keep doing this until you find some activity. Once you find the zone in which they are biting, focus on that area each time you drop your bait.

When is it safe to start ice fishing?

Always check with the local bait shop or your state agency before going on the ice. A good rule of thumb is to wait until the ice is 4 inches thick. A general rule of thumb is ice is safe when it's four inches thick, which usually occurs after a week's worth of nights where the temperature is below freezing. Check with your state agency or local bait and tackle shop on ice conditions before heading out to ice fish. Once out near the lake or pond, always check the ice thickness before venturing out.

What types of fish can I catch while ice fishing?

Shallow water weed beds in the Midwest predominantly have bluegills and often crappies. Perch are usually found in colder deeper lakes especially in the Dakotas. Tip up fisherman using minnows or roaches for bait will be targeting larger species like Northern Pike or Muskellunge.

If I am not able to purchase a new rod, which of my current rods could I use?

Ice fishing rods use float bobbers or spring bobbers for strike indicators. The floats used in ice fishing are much smaller than what is used in open water fishing. You can always find fishing rod and reel combos at the local bait store. Worst case scenario is to borrow one from a fellow fisherman.

What types of equipment do I need to take ice fishing other than the basic rod or tip-up?

If you plan to fish a community spot or shanty town as long as the weather isn't extremely cold, holes should be open so an auger isn’t necessary if you don't already have one. And you can always ask to borrow one or have an angler drill a hole for you. Basic necessities are fishing pole with spring bobber, small jigs, bait, bucket to sit on and warm clothes. Learn more about ice fishing gear and Fly tying hooks

What other activities can I do while I ice fish?

Kids love to play on the ice and in the snow. Most of the time it's not necessary to have other activities planned. They will find a way to have fun. Family gatherings are always more fun outside when there is hot food. So bring a grill along and cook some hot dogs. Plan to make friends and bring along plenty of extras.

Content courtesy of the USA Ice Team.
Photo courtesy of Michigan Department of Natural Resources